INDIANAPOLIS - Four members of the IU Indianapolis women's soccer team earned #HLWSOC All-League honors as voted on by the league head coaches, as announced by the league office on Friday (Nov. 6). Junior forward Keilah Muldrow was voted First Team All-League while junior midfielder Annaliese Black was chosen to the second team. Junior defender Bethany Hartigan and senior Caroline Kelley were voted third team while Kelley was also named recipient of the league's Sportsmanship Award. 

Muldrow was one of the league's top attackers all season long, finishing the regular season tied for third in the league in goals (8) and ranking third overall in points (18). She also ranked among the league leaders in shots (43) and shots on goal (23) and scored six of her eight goals in Horizon League play. She tallied a pair of goals in the Horizon League opener against Milwaukee and had points in six of the Jaguars' league games. Her two game-winning goals came at Purdue Fort Wayne (Oct. 4) and against Oakland (Oct. 15). 

Black emerged as one of the top playmakers in the league, ranking second in the Horizon League in assists (7) during the regular season to go along with four goals. She had two assists in a game in victories over Bellarmine (Sept 3) and at Purdue Fort Wayne (Oct. 4). She also tallied the game-winner against Bellarmine and had a game with a goal and an assist against Detroit Mercy (Oct. 18). 

Hartigan was the team's top defender, logging a team-high 1,656 minutes, playing nearly 97 percent of the team's minutes. She finished the season with two goals and two assists, including netting the game-winner in the 1-0 regular season finale over Northern Illinois (Oct. 30) when the Jags clinched a spot in the Horizon League Tournament. She played all 90 minutes in 15 of the team's 19 matches and sat just 10 total minutes during Horizon League play. 

Kelley finished the regular season with five goals and five assists and led the team in game-winners (3), shots (50) and shots on goal (28). Kelley finished the regular season strong, contributing points in four of the final five matches of the season, including a pair of goals in a 4-2 win over Detroit Mercy (Oct. 18). She also had game-winning goals against Chicago State (Aug. 30) and at Robert Morris (Oct. 22). Kelley was voted as the league's Sportsmanship Award winner, having gone 74 career games and over 5,000 minutes in her collegiate career without being issued a yellow card, despite being the team's primary attacking target. 

The full list of this year's honorees is below. 

2026 Horizon League Women's Soccer Award Winners
Player of the Year: Emily Petring, Milwaukee
Goalkeeper of the Year: Hayleigh Lewis, Cleveland State
Offensive Player of the Year: Megan Molner, Northern Kentucky
Defensive Player of the Year:  Emily Urban, Milwaukee
Freshman of the Year: Emily Urban, Milwaukee
Sportsmanship Award: Caroline Kelley, IU Indianapolis
Coach of the Year: Kevin Boyd, Milwaukee
 
All-League First Team
Hayleigh Lewis, Cleveland State, Goalkeeper
Jess Howard, Green Bay, Defender
Laney Stark, Green Bay, Forward
Rebecca Stoeckmann, Green Bay, Midfielder
Keilah Muldrow, IU Indianapolis, Forward
Emily Petring, Milwaukee, Forward
Emily Urban, Milwaukee, Defender
Natalie Zodrow, Milwaukee, Midfielder
Megan Molner, Northern Kentucky, Forward
Caitlin Burger, Wright State, Midfielder
Kate Makkas, Youngstown State, Defender
 
All-League Second Team
Alyssa Flood, Green Bay, Defender
Annaliese Black, IU Indianapolis, Midfielder
Ashlyn Derosier, Milwaukee, Midfielder
Lauren Nidey, Milwaukee, Goalkeeper
Ashlyn Skinner-Barrett, Milwaukee, Forward
Kiersten White, Milwaukee, Defender
Erykah Cornett, Northern Kentucky, Forward
Emma Gianino, Northern Kentucky, Midfielder
Sophia Kapszukiewicz, Northern Kentucky, Defender
Camille Bultel, Youngstown State, Midfielder
Sara Felder, Youngstown State, Forward
 
All-League Third Team                
Bella Brozek, Green Bay, Forward
Aixa Helbringer-Escobar, Green Bay, Midfielder
Anna Scott, Green Bay, Goalkeeper
Bethany Hartigan, IU Indianapolis, Defender
Caroline Kelley, IU Indianapolis, Forward
Denise Camerena, Milwaukee, Midfielder
Payton Green, Milwaukee, Defender
Caitlin Evans, Northern Kentucky, Defender
Brae Cole, Oakland, Defender
Makenzie Chinn, Wright State, Midfielder
Ruby Dunlevy, Wright State, Forward
 
Sportsmanship Award Finalists
Olivia Cruz, Cleveland State
Leila Lanier, Detroit Mercy
Rebecca Stoeckmann, Green Bay
Caroline Kelley, IU Indianapolis*
Denise Camerena, Milwaukee
Lauren Mrugala, NIU
Natalie Newman, Northern Kentucky
Ella Shapiro, Oakland
Jenna Ellsworth, Purdue Fort Wayne
Emma Cameron, RMU
Addy Canter, Wright State
Makayla Thinger, Youngstown State